UMM Logo

Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang


Free Download Journals Directory


International Journal of Law and Management

The Rhetoric of Eunomia

Euan MacDonald
Research Officer, Institute for International Law and Justice, New York University
Abstract :

This paper presents a detailed analysis of Philip Allott’s 1991 work Eunomia: New Order for a New World.  It begins by briefly framing the work in terms of what is here referred to as “the critical challenge” to international law, and suggests that one central goal of the text an attempted synthesis of the old opposition between philosophy and literature.  It then sketches an outline of the manner in which his thesis is constructed – noting, in doing so, that despite the scope and complexity of the book, there is relatively little in the way of standard academic argument to be found therein.  This leads on to the central focus of this paper: the manner in which Allott seeks to construct authority for the claims he makes and conclusions he reaches in the absence of such argumentation.  To this end, the main bulk of the paper is concerned, in a manner influenced by theorists such as Chaïm Perelman and James Boyd White, with performing a critical analysis of the rhetorics of the work.  It considers issues such as enacted dialectics; language; voice; metaphor; and technique; analysing each in turn for the way in which they function to bolster Allott’s otherwise nakedly – if eloquently – asserted claims.  It concludes that, while the early promise of Eunomia is undoubtedly that of confronting the irreducible contradictions and aporia identified as inevitable in the critical challenge to international law, these themes are gradually worked out and ultimately usurped – in both the rhetorics and the surface meaning of the text – by those of transcendence, unity and systemic completion; the hallmarks of Allott’s mystification of society.

Keywords :
The Structures of Eunomia, The Rhetoric of Eunomia

Date Deposited : 24 Mar 2016 12:01

Last Modified : 24 Mar 2016 12:01

Official URL: http://www.iilj.org/publications/

Volume 2008, Number 1, - 2008 , ISSN 1552-6275

Download:
Full Text Original
Abstract : pdf doc
Home | Peta Situs | Admissions | Student Research | E-Journal
Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang © 2011
Developed by Infokom UMM
Last Update : 13 December 2016 20:46Kumpulan file jurnal