UMM Logo

Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Free Download Journals Directory

International Journal of Law and Management

.: Home > International Journal of Law and Management > 2009 > Volume 2009 Number 6 > Benedict Kingsbury, Stephan Schill

Investor-State Arbitration as Governance: Fair and Equitable Treatment, Proportionality and the Emerging Global Administrative Law

Benedict Kingsbury, Stephan Schill
NYU School of Law International Arbitration Law Clerk to the Hon. Charles N. Brower, London; Rechtsanwalt; Attorney-at-Law, New York
Abstract :

Investor-State arbitration is not only a mechanism to settle disputes between an investor and a State arising out of an investment, it is also a form of global governance that involves the exercise of power by arbitral tribunals in the global administrative space. In setting standards for State conduct vis-à-vis foreign investors, for example in defining what is improper administration or a violation of due process under fair and equitable treatment, tribunals set standards which may influence future conduct by the respondent State and other States, and will very likely influence the decision-making of tribunals in other cases.  In settling disputes between investors and States, the tribunals also act as pre-agreed review agencies of a State’s specific actions, in some cases applying proportionality analysis or other tools of public law review when confronted with difficult balances between investor protection and the State’s environmental or economic policy choices in the wider public interest.  In these respects, investor-State arbitration forms part of a governance structure, and helps constitute and shape the emerging body of global administrative law.  At the same time, this regulatory activity of arbitral tribunals attracts significant criticism, not only of specific decisions but with regard to the legitimacy of the decision-making powers of these tribunals as such.  This paper argues that these concerns can be addressed, at least in part, by application of principles of the emerging global administrative law to, and by, these tribunals.

Keywords :
Investor-State arbitration, global administrative law, investment treaty

Date Deposited : 28 Mar 2016 14:44

Last Modified : 28 Mar 2016 14:44

Official URL:

Volume 2009, Number 6, - 2009 , ISSN 1552-6275

Full Text Original
Abstract : pdf doc